%PDF-1.3
%%
%%Page: 1 1
4 0 obj
<<
/Length 5 0 R
>>
stream
q
BT
0 Tr
0 g
1 0 0 1 156 664.5 Tm
/F1 13 Tf 100 Tz
88.1395 -8.4 Td
1.3 Tw
0 Tc
(FOR PUBLICATION) Tj
/F1 15 Tf 100 Tz
-78.2395 -24 Td
1.5 Tw
(UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS) Tj
43.47 -16 Td
(FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
-53.37 -18 Td
1.2 Tw
() Tj
0 Tw
( ) Tj
1.2 Tw
0 0 Td
183.8 0 Td
/F3 20 Tf 100 Tz
-2.18 -17.6 Td
2 Tw
() Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
-181.62 -2.8 Td
1.2 Tw
(P) Tj
/F2 8.4 Tf 101.1 Tz
.79 Tw
(HILLIP) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
1.2 Tw
( G. L) Tj
/F2 8.4 Tf 101.1 Tz
.79 Tw
(AWRENCE) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
1.2 Tw
(, and all other) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
(persons similarly situated,) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
80.988 -13.2 Td
(Plaintiff-Appellant,) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
134.082 0 Td
(No. 06-35448) Tj
-132.57 -18 Td
(v.) Tj
144.234 0 Td
(D.C. No.) Tj
/F3 20 Tf 100 Tz
-45.114 -7.9 Td
2 Tw
() Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
21.714 -5.3 Td
1.2 Tw
(CV-04-00203-EFS) Tj
-203.334 -4.8 Td
(D) Tj
/F2 8.4 Tf 101.1 Tz
.79 Tw
(EPARTMENT OF) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
1.2 Tw
( I) Tj
/F2 8.4 Tf 101.1 Tz
.79 Tw
(NTERIOR) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
1.2 Tw
(, agency;) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
(D) Tj
/F2 8.4 Tf 101.1 Tz
.79 Tw
(IRK) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
1.2 Tw
( K) Tj
/F2 8.4 Tf 101.1 Tz
.79 Tw
(EMPTHORNE) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
1.2 Tw
(,*) Tj
( Secretary of) Tj
224.34 0 Td
(OPINION) Tj
-224.34 -13.2 Td
(the Department of the Interior,) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
65.688 -13.2 Td
(Defendants-Appellees.) Tj
/F3 20 Tf 100 Tz
115.932 -8.8 Td
1.6 Ts
2 Tw
() Tj
0 Ts
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
-142.878 -26.2 Td
1.2 Tw
(Appeal from the United States District Court) Tj
16.44 -13.2 Td
(for the Eastern District of Washington) Tj
-8.508 -13.2 Td
(Edward F. Shea, District Judge, Presiding) Tj
47.796 -26.2 Td
(Argued and Submitted) Tj
-45.426 -13.2 Td
(November 7, 2007Seattle, Washington) Tj
51.822 -26.2 Td
(Filed May 13, 2008) Tj
-78.318 -26.2 Td
(Before: William) Tj
0 Tw
( ) Tj
1.2 Tw
(C.) Tj
0 Tw
( ) Tj
1.2 Tw
(Canby,) Tj
0 Tw
( ) Tj
1.2 Tw
(Jr., Susan) Tj
0 Tw
( ) Tj
1.2 Tw
(P.) Tj
0 Tw
( ) Tj
1.2 Tw
(Graber, and) Tj
45.684 -13.2 Td
(Ronald) Tj
0 Tw
( ) Tj
1.2 Tw
(M.) Tj
0 Tw
( ) Tj
1.2 Tw
(Gould, Circuit) Tj
0 Tw
( ) Tj
1.2 Tw
(Judges.) Tj
20.136 -26.2 Td
(Opinion by Judge Canby) Tj
ET
Q
q
1 0 0 1 156 664.5 cm
0 G
.9 w 0 -65.95 m 183.8 -65.95 l s
1.2 w 186.6 -123.5 m 186.6 -73.8 l s
1.2 w 186.6 -190.2 m 186.6 -140.5 l s
.9 w 0 -197.15 m 183.3 -197.15 l s
Q
q
BT
0 Tr
0 g
1 0 0 1 156 200.9 Tm
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
148.5 -1 Td
1.2 Tw
0 Tc
() Tj
0 Tw
( ) Tj
1.2 Tw
/F2 10 Tf 100 Tz
-138.5 -26 Td
1.45 Tw
(*Dirk Kempthorne is substituted for his predecessor, Gale Norton, as) Tj
-10 -11.2 Td
1.4 Tw
(Secretary of the Department of the Interior, pursuant to F) Tj
/F2 7 Tf 101.4 Tz
1.38 Tw
(ED) Tj
/F2 10 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
1.4 Tw
(. R. A) Tj
/F2 7 Tf 101.4 Tz
1.38 Tw
(PP) Tj
/F2 10 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
1.4 Tw
(. P.) Tj
0 -11.2 Td
1 Tw
(43\(c\)\(2\). ) Tj
ET
Q
q
1 0 0 1 156 200.9 cm
0 G
.5 w 0 -12.75 m 300 -12.75 l s
Q
q
BT
0 Tr
0 g
1 0 0 1 0 792 Tm
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
295 -664.5 Td
1.1 Tw
0 Tc
(5401) Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
5 0 obj
3202
endobj
3 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Parent 10 0 R
/Resources <<
/Font <<
/F1 6 0 R
/F2 7 0 R
/F3 8 0 R
/F4 9 0 R
>>
/ProcSet 1 0 R
>>
/Contents 4 0 R
>>
endobj
%%Page: 2 2
12 0 obj
<<
/Length 13 0 R
>>
stream
q
BT
0 Tr
0 g
1 0 0 1 156 643.5 Tm
/F1 12 Tf 100 Tz
120.996 -27.6 Td
1.2 Tw
0 Tc
(COUNSEL) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
-120.996 -26.2 Td
(Richard B. Price, Omak, Washington, for the appellant. ) Tj
0 -26.2 Td
2.28 Tw
(Andrew S. Biviano, Assistant United States Attorney, Spo-) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
1.2 Tw
(kane, Washington, for the appellees. ) Tj
/F1 12 Tf 100 Tz
123.666 -44.2 Td
(OPINION) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
-123.666 -26.2 Td
(CANBY, Circuit Judge: ) Tj
12 -26.2 Td
2.03 Tw
(Phillip Lawrence, a member of the Standing Rock Sioux) Tj
-12 -13.2 Td
3.85 Tw
(Indian Tribe, has been employed for many years by the) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
1.55 Tw
(Bureau of Indian Affairs \() Tj
(BIA) Tj
(\). He brought this action to) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
1.28 Tw
(challenge the denial of increased retirement benefits payable) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
1.81 Tw
(to employees whose duties included firefighting. He alleges) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
.02 Tw
(that the BIA failed to notify him of an application deadline for) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
2.45 Tw
(retroactive reclassifications of service to reflect firefighting) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
.4 Tw
(service. As a result of this failure, Lawrence missed the dead-) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
.18 Tw
(line and corresponding benefits were denied. In this action, he) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
.26 Tw
(claims that the BIA's failure to notify him constituted a viola-) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
.95 Tw
(tion of federal trust responsibility toward Indians, a violation) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
.75 Tw
(of the Indian Preference Act, and employment discrimination) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
.37 Tw
(on the basis of race. The district court granted summary judg-) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
1.2 Tw
(ment for the BIA, and we affirm. ) Tj
/F1 12 Tf 100 Tz
130.332 -26.2 Td
(FACTS) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
-118.332 -26.2 Td
1.1 Tw
(Since June 1976, Lawrence has worked with the BIA as a) Tj
-12 -13.2 Td
3.14 Tw
(forester and silviculturalist. The ) Tj
(job descriptions for those) Tj
ET
Q
q
1 0 0 1 156 643.5 cm
0 G
.5 w 0 -8.15 m 300 -8.15 l s
.5 w 0 -117.95 m 300 -117.95 l s
Q
q
BT
0 Tr
0 g
1 0 0 1 0 792 Tm
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
434 -136.5 Td
1.1 Tw
0 Tc
(5403) Tj
-198.3682 0 Td
(L) Tj
/F2 7.7 Tf 101.2 Tz
.79 Tw
(AWRENCE) Tj
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
1.1 Tw
( v. D) Tj
/F2 7.7 Tf 101.2 Tz
.79 Tw
(EP) Tj
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
1.1 Tw
(') Tj
/F2 7.7 Tf 101.2 Tz
.79 Tw
(T OF) Tj
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
1.1 Tw
( I) Tj
/F2 7.7 Tf 101.2 Tz
.79 Tw
(NTERIOR) Tj
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
ET
Q
q
1 0 0 1 0 792 cm
0 G
.5 w 156 -140.25 m 456 -140.25 l s
Q
endstream
endobj
13 0 obj
2550
endobj
11 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Parent 10 0 R
/Resources <<
/Font <<
/F1 6 0 R
/F2 7 0 R
>>
/ProcSet 1 0 R
>>
/Contents 12 0 R
>>
endobj
%%Page: 3 3
15 0 obj
<<
/Length 16 0 R
>>
stream
q
BT
0 Tr
0 g
1 0 0 1 156 643.5 Tm
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
0 -8.4 Td
.55 Tw
0 Tc
(positions did not specify that his duties included fire suppres-) Tj
0 -14 Td
1.71 Tw
(sion. Nonetheless, during fire season, Lawrence spent much) Tj
0 -14 Td
1.2 Tw
(of his work-time fighting fires. ) Tj
12 -27.6 Td
1.95 Tw
(The Civil Service Retirement System grants an enhanced) Tj
-12 -13.9 Td
3 Tw
(benefit retirement program to firefighters credited with 20) Tj
0 -13.9 Td
.14 Tw
(years of service. 5 U.S.C. ) Tj
0 Tw
( ) Tj
.14 Tw
(8336\(c\)\(1\). In order to be credited) Tj
0 -13.9 Td
3.91 Tw
(for service as firefighters, employees like Lawrence who) Tj
0 -13.9 Td
.82 Tw
(serve in positions not approved as firefighting positions must) Tj
0 -13.9 Td
1.2 Tw
(apply for the credit and prove that their duties included fire-) Tj
0 -13.9 Td
2.57 Tw
(fighting. 5 C.F.R. ) Tj
0 Tw
( ) Tj
2.57 Tw
(831.906\(b\). In 1987, the Civil Service) Tj
0 -13.9 Td
1.27 Tw
(regulations were changed so that the credit for years of fire-) Tj
0 -13.9 Td
.33 Tw
(fighting would reach back only one year prior to making such) Tj
0 -13.9 Td
2.28 Tw
(an application. ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(See ) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
(5 C.F.R. ) Tj
0 Tw
( ) Tj
2.28 Tw
(831.906\(e\). The change was) Tj
0 -13.9 Td
1.06 Tw
(published in the ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(Federal Register) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
(. 52 Fed. Reg. 47893 \(Dec.) Tj
0 -13.9 Td
3.9 Tw
(17, 1987\). Under the new regulation, existing employees) Tj
0 -13.9 Td
.47 Tw
(would receive credit for their entire career if they filed before) Tj
0 -13.9 Td
1.2 Tw
(September 30, 1989. 52 Fed. Reg. at 47896. ) Tj
12 -27.6 Td
.85 Tw
(In the months that followed publication of the new regula-) Tj
-12 -13.9 Td
1.81 Tw
(tion, the BIA issued several ) Tj
(Personnel Management Bulle-) Tj
0 -13.9 Td
5.66 Tw
(tins to agency personnel officers, superintendents, and) Tj
0 -13.9 Td
1.41 Tw
(division chiefs instructing them to pay ) Tj
(special attention) Tj
( to) Tj
0 -13.9 Td
.03 Tw
(the new deadline and ) Tj
(insure that Bureau employees who may) Tj
0 -13.9 Td
1.66 Tw
(be eligible under the special retirement provisions are again) Tj
0 -13.9 Td
2.62 Tw
(reminded) Tj
( of it. Nonetheless, Lawrence received no actual) Tj
0 -13.9 Td
1.04 Tw
(notice of the change until December 1998, when the Depart-) Tj
0 -13.9 Td
1.15 Tw
(ment of the Interior held a firefighters' and law enforcement) Tj
0 -13.9 Td
3.66 Tw
(officers' retirement workshop on the Colville Reservation) Tj
0 -13.9 Td
2.11 Tw
(where Lawrence worked. There, Lawrence was erroneously) Tj
0 -13.9 Td
1.22 Tw
(advised that if he filed a claim within one year of the work-) Tj
0 -13.9 Td
.72 Tw
(shop, the claim would cover the course of his entire career at) Tj
0 -13.9 Td
1.2 Tw
(the agency.) Tj
4.9 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
.5 Tw
(1) Tj
0 Ts
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
1.2 Tw
( ) Tj
/F2 10 Tf 100 Tz
10 -27.3 Td
4.1 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
.43 Tw
(1) Tj
0 Ts
/F2 10 Tf 100 Tz
(At the time this advice was given, the deadline was nine years past for) Tj
-10 -11.7 Td
1 Tw
(full recognition of Lawrence's career firefighting services. ) Tj
ET
Q
q
1 0 0 1 156 643.5 cm
0 G
.5 w 0 -465.35 m 300 -465.35 l s
Q
q
BT
0 Tr
0 g
1 0 0 1 0 792 Tm
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
156 -136.5 Td
1.1 Tw
0 Tc
(5404) Tj
79.6318 0 Td
(L) Tj
/F2 7.7 Tf 101.2 Tz
.79 Tw
(AWRENCE) Tj
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
1.1 Tw
( v. D) Tj
/F2 7.7 Tf 101.2 Tz
.79 Tw
(EP) Tj
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
1.1 Tw
(') Tj
/F2 7.7 Tf 101.2 Tz
.79 Tw
(T OF) Tj
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
1.1 Tw
( I) Tj
/F2 7.7 Tf 101.2 Tz
.79 Tw
(NTERIOR) Tj
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
ET
Q
q
1 0 0 1 0 792 cm
0 G
.5 w 156 -140.25 m 456 -140.25 l s
Q
endstream
endobj
16 0 obj
3811
endobj
14 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Parent 10 0 R
/Resources <<
/Font <<
/F1 6 0 R
/F2 7 0 R
/F4 9 0 R
/F5 17 0 R
>>
/ProcSet 1 0 R
>>
/Contents 15 0 R
>>
endobj
%%Page: 4 4
19 0 obj
<<
/Length 20 0 R
>>
stream
q
BT
0 Tr
0 g
1 0 0 1 156 643.5 Tm
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
12 -8.4 Td
.63 Tw
0 Tc
(Lawrence filed his claim on May 5, 1999. The Department) Tj
-12 -13 Td
2.17 Tw
(determined that the request for pre-1998 service credit was) Tj
0 -13 Td
-.96 Tw
(barred by the one-year rule and denied that portion of the claim.) Tj
4.9 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
(2) Tj
0 Ts
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
0 -13 Td
.96 Tw
(Title 5 C.F.R. ) Tj
0 Tw
( ) Tj
.96 Tw
(831.906\(f\) allows the agency head to extend) Tj
0 -13 Td
.33 Tw
(the time limit for filing if ) Tj
(the individual shows that he or she) Tj
0 -13 Td
2.66 Tw
(was prevented by circumstances beyond his or her control) Tj
0 -13 Td
1.25 Tw
(from making the request within the time limit.) Tj
( The Depart-) Tj
0 -13 Td
1.74 Tw
(ment found that Lawrence's ignorance of the time limit did) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
1.2 Tw
(not constitute a circumstance beyond his control. ) Tj
12 -26 Td
2.5 Tw
(Lawrence sought review of this decision from the Merit) Tj
-12 -13.1 Td
1.2 Tw
(Systems Protection Board. The Board denied his petition for) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
.75 Tw
(review. Lawrence challenged this denial in the district court.) Tj
4.9 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
(3) Tj
0 Ts
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
0 -13.1 Td
1.8 Tw
(He argued, ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(inter alia) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
(, that the BIA's failure to provide him) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
1.14 Tw
(with actual and timely notice of the 1987 regulation limiting) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
1.25 Tw
(claims violated the BIA's obligations to Lawrence under the) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
.47 Tw
(federal trust responsibility toward Indians, violated the Indian) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
3.28 Tw
(Preference Act, and constituted unlawful employment dis-) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
4.95 Tw
(crimination in violation of Title VII. The district court) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
4.33 Tw
(rejected these arguments and granted summary judgment) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
.33 Tw
(against Lawrence, who brought this appeal. We have jurisdic-) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
1.2 Tw
(tion pursuant to 28 U.S.C. ) Tj
0 Tw
( ) Tj
1.2 Tw
(1291. ) Tj
/F1 12 Tf 100 Tz
113.328 -26 Td
(DISCUSSION) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
-101.328 -26 Td
.52 Tw
(We review a grant of summary judgment de novo, viewing) Tj
-12 -13.1 Td
1.81 Tw
(the agency's decision from the same position as the district) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
1.99 Tw
(court. ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(Sierra Club v. Babbitt) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
(, 65 F.3d 1502, 1507 \(9th Cir.) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
.03 Tw
(1995\). A court reviewing a decision of the Merit Systems Pro-) Tj
/F2 10 Tf 100 Tz
10 -25.8 Td
4.1 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
.72 Tw
(2) Tj
0 Ts
/F2 10 Tf 100 Tz
(The Department also initially denied benefits for the period after May) Tj
-10 -11.2 Td
1.13 Tw
(4, 1998, but that portion of the decision has been rescinded. That denial) Tj
0 -11.2 Td
1 Tw
(is not before the court. ) Tj
10 -13.9 Td
4.1 Ts
/F5 6 Tf 100 Tz
.27 Tw
(3) Tj
0 Ts
/F2 10 Tf 100 Tz
(Although appeals of Merit Systems Protection Board decisions gener-) Tj
-10 -11.2 Td
.95 Tw
(ally must be filed in the Federal Circuit Court of Appeals, district courts) Tj
0 -11.2 Td
0 Tw
(have jurisdiction to review `mixed' cases, in which an action involves both) Tj
0 -11.2 Td
.19 Tw
(a Merit Systems Protection Act appeal and a discrimination claim.) Tj
( ) Tj
/F4 10 Tf 100 Tz
(Coons) Tj
0 -11.2 Td
1.48 Tw
(v. Sec'y of the U.S. Dep't of the Treasury, ) Tj
/F2 10 Tf 100 Tz
(383 F.3d 879, 884 \(9th Cir.) Tj
0 -11.2 Td
1 Tw
(2004\) \(citing 5 U.S.C. ) Tj
0 Tw
( ) Tj
1 Tw
(7703\(b\)\(2\)\). ) Tj
ET
Q
q
1 0 0 1 156 643.5 cm
0 G
.5 w 0 -385.55 m 300 -385.55 l s
Q
q
BT
0 Tr
0 g
1 0 0 1 0 792 Tm
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
434 -136.5 Td
1.1 Tw
0 Tc
(5405) Tj
-198.3682 0 Td
(L) Tj
/F2 7.7 Tf 101.2 Tz
.79 Tw
(AWRENCE) Tj
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
1.1 Tw
( v. D) Tj
/F2 7.7 Tf 101.2 Tz
.79 Tw
(EP) Tj
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
1.1 Tw
(') Tj
/F2 7.7 Tf 101.2 Tz
.79 Tw
(T OF) Tj
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
1.1 Tw
( I) Tj
/F2 7.7 Tf 101.2 Tz
.79 Tw
(NTERIOR) Tj
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
ET
Q
q
1 0 0 1 0 792 cm
0 G
.5 w 156 -140.25 m 456 -140.25 l s
Q
endstream
endobj
20 0 obj
4157
endobj
18 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Parent 10 0 R
/Resources <<
/Font <<
/F1 6 0 R
/F2 7 0 R
/F4 9 0 R
/F5 17 0 R
>>
/ProcSet 1 0 R
>>
/Contents 19 0 R
>>
endobj
%%Page: 5 5
22 0 obj
<<
/Length 23 0 R
>>
stream
q
BT
0 Tr
0 g
1 0 0 1 156 643.5 Tm
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
0 -8.4 Td
.92 Tw
0 Tc
(tection Board must ) Tj
(set aside any agency action, findings, or) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
1.2 Tw
(conclusions found to be) Tj
22 -26 Td
1.06 Tw
(\(1\)) Tj
9 Tw
( ) Tj
1.06 Tw
(arbitrary, capricious, an abuse of discretion, or) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
1.2 Tw
(otherwise not in accordance with law; ) Tj
0 -26 Td
2.4 Tw
(\(2\)) Tj
9 Tw
( ) Tj
2.4 Tw
(obtained without procedures required by law,) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
1.2 Tw
(rule, or regulation having been followed; or ) Tj
0 -26 Td
(\(3\)) Tj
9 Tw
( ) Tj
1.2 Tw
(unsupported by substantial evidence . . . .) Tj
( ) Tj
-22 -26 Td
.23 Tw
(5 U.S.C. ) Tj
0 Tw
( ) Tj
.23 Tw
(7703\(c\); ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(see Coons, ) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
(383 F.3d at 888. An employee) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
2.66 Tw
(asserting Title VII discrimination claims in such review is) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
1.2 Tw
(entitled to trial de novo of that claim. 5) Tj
0 Tw
( ) Tj
1.2 Tw
(U.S.C. ) Tj
0 Tw
( ) Tj
1.2 Tw
(7703\(c\). ) Tj
/F1 12 Tf 100 Tz
12 -26 Td
1.71 Tw
([1]) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
( Under generally applicable civil service law, the gov-) Tj
-12 -13.1 Td
.36 Tw
(ernment did not waive the time limit of 5 C.F.R. ) Tj
0 Tw
( ) Tj
.36 Tw
(831.906\(e\)) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
1.96 Tw
(by failing to provide actual notice of the new time limit to) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
2.92 Tw
(current employees. ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(Stearn v. Dep't of the Navy) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
(, 280 F.3d) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
.78 Tw
(1376, 1384-85 \(Fed. Cir. 2002\). As ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(Stearn) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
( provides, publica-) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
1.07 Tw
(tion in the Federal Register suffices as constructive notice to) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
1.5 Tw
(Lawrence of the limitations period. ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(Id. ) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
(Although the regula-) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
.11 Tw
(tion does provide for waiver when the employee is ) Tj
(prevented) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
1.14 Tw
(by circumstances beyond his or her control from making the) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
.66 Tw
(request within the time limit,) Tj
( 5 C.F.R. ) Tj
0 Tw
( ) Tj
.66 Tw
(831.906\(f\), no such) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
1.2 Tw
(circumstances were present in this case. ) Tj
/F1 12 Tf 100 Tz
12 -26.1 Td
3 Tw
([2]) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
( The federal government's trust responsibility toward) Tj
-12 -13.1 Td
2.84 Tw
(Indian tribes does not change the rule. This is not a case) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
1.66 Tw
(where the United States holds assets in trust for a tribe and) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
1.36 Tw
(has a fiduciary obligation to provide actual notice to benefi-) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
.27 Tw
(ciaries of their claims. ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(See ) Tj
(Loudner v. United States) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
(, 108 F.3d) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
1.11 Tw
(896, 900-01 \(8th Cir. 1997\). The agency discharged its fidu-) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
.16 Tw
(ciary obligations by complying with the Civil Service Regula-) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
6.57 Tw
(tions, which are ) Tj
(general regulations and statutes not) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
.18 Tw
(specifically aimed at protecting Indian tribes.) Tj
( ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(Morongo Band) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
.27 Tw
(of Mission Indians v. FAA) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
(, 161 F.3d 569, 574 \(9th Cir. 1998\).) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
2.33 Tw
(The agency's failure to provide employees with actual and) Tj
1 0 0 1 0 792 Tm
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
156 -136.5 Td
1.1 Tw
0 Tc
(5406) Tj
79.6318 0 Td
(L) Tj
/F2 7.7 Tf 101.2 Tz
.79 Tw
(AWRENCE) Tj
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
1.1 Tw
( v. D) Tj
/F2 7.7 Tf 101.2 Tz
.79 Tw
(EP) Tj
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
1.1 Tw
(') Tj
/F2 7.7 Tf 101.2 Tz
.79 Tw
(T OF) Tj
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
1.1 Tw
( I) Tj
/F2 7.7 Tf 101.2 Tz
.79 Tw
(NTERIOR) Tj
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
ET
Q
q
1 0 0 1 0 792 cm
0 G
.5 w 156 -140.25 m 456 -140.25 l s
Q
endstream
endobj
23 0 obj
3882
endobj
21 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Parent 10 0 R
/Resources <<
/Font <<
/F1 6 0 R
/F2 7 0 R
/F4 9 0 R
>>
/ProcSet 1 0 R
>>
/Contents 22 0 R
>>
endobj
%%Page: 6 6
25 0 obj
<<
/Length 26 0 R
>>
stream
q
BT
0 Tr
0 g
1 0 0 1 156 643.5 Tm
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
0 -8.4 Td
5.67 Tw
0 Tc
(timely notice of the regulatory change is regrettable) Tj
0 -13 Td
1.33 Tw
(particularly in light of the agency's repeated written instruc-) Tj
0 -13 Td
.41 Tw
(tions to supervisors to provide such noticebut trust doctrine) Tj
0 -13 Td
1.57 Tw
(imposes no special notice obligation beyond that enunciated) Tj
0 -13 Td
1.2 Tw
(in ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(Stearn) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
(. ) Tj
/F1 12 Tf 100 Tz
12 -26 Td
2.01 Tw
([3]) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
( Lawrence fares no better under the Indian Preference) Tj
-12 -13 Td
.79 Tw
(Act. The text of this act accords Indians a preference in ) Tj
(hir-) Tj
0 -13 Td
.27 Tw
(ing, 25 U.S.C. ) Tj
0 Tw
( ) Tj
.27 Tw
(472, and the BIA has interpreted ) Tj
(hiring) Tj
( to) Tj
0 -13 Td
1.71 Tw
(mean ) Tj
(initial hiring, reinstatement, transfer, reassignment or) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
.91 Tw
(promotion.) Tj
( 25 C.F.R. ) Tj
0 Tw
( ) Tj
.91 Tw
(5.2\(a\). This preference of 25 U.S.C.) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
3.61 Tw
() Tj
0 Tw
( ) Tj
3.61 Tw
(472 supersedes the otherwise ) Tj
(blind) Tj
( application of the) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
.06 Tw
(Civil Service Regulations in the hiring of Indians. ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(See ) Tj
(Preston) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
.11 Tw
(v. Heckler) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
(, 734 F.2d 1359, 1370-71 \(9th Cir. 1984\). Lawrence) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
2.71 Tw
(argues that the word ) Tj
(reassignment) Tj
( extends to retroactive) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
.14 Tw
(recognition that his employment included firefighting for ben-) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
3.05 Tw
(efits purposes, and that the preference accordingly applies) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
1.26 Tw
(here. While ) Tj
(statutes enacted for the benefit of Indians must) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
.67 Tw
(be liberally construed with all doubts resolved in favor of the) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
1.85 Tw
(Indians,) Tj
( ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(id.) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
( at 1369, we cannot read ) Tj
(hiring) Tj
( or ) Tj
(reassign-) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
1.36 Tw
(ment so broadly as to include a retroactive recognition that) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
2.16 Tw
(Lawrence's duties included firefighting. The Merit Systems) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
1.42 Tw
(Protection Board therefore did not act arbitrarily or contrary) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
1.66 Tw
(to law in holding that the limited imperatives of the Prefer-) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
.91 Tw
(ence Act do not apply to this case. With regard to the matter) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
1.7 Tw
(in issue, the regular provisions of the Civil Service Regula-) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
1.2 Tw
(tions govern Lawrence as they do any other employee. ) Tj
/F1 12 Tf 100 Tz
12 -26 Td
.36 Tw
([4]) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
( Finally, the district court did not err when it granted the) Tj
-12 -13.1 Td
1.78 Tw
(Department's motion for summary judgment on Lawrence's) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
.06 Tw
(disparate impact claim. ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(See ) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
(Civil Rights Act of 1964 ) Tj
0 Tw
( ) Tj
.06 Tw
(717\(a\),) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
0 -13.1 Td
.91 Tw
(as amended) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
(, 42 U.S.C. ) Tj
0 Tw
( ) Tj
.91 Tw
(2000e-16. Lawrence failed to make) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
1.03 Tw
(a prima facie showing of disparate impact, which is ) Tj
(usually) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
.42 Tw
(accomplished by statistical evidence showing that an employ-) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
1.4 Tw
(ment practice selects members of a protected class in a pro-) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
2.7 Tw
(portion smaller than their percentage in the pool of actual) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
2.4 Tw
(applicants. ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(Stout v. Potter) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
(, 276 F.3d 1118, 1122 \(9th Cir.) Tj
0 -13.1 Td
.08 Tw
(2002\) \(internal quotation marks omitted\) \(quoting ) Tj
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
(Robinson v.) Tj
1 0 0 1 0 792 Tm
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
434 -136.5 Td
1.1 Tw
0 Tc
(5407) Tj
-198.3682 0 Td
(L) Tj
/F2 7.7 Tf 101.2 Tz
.79 Tw
(AWRENCE) Tj
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
1.1 Tw
( v. D) Tj
/F2 7.7 Tf 101.2 Tz
.79 Tw
(EP) Tj
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
1.1 Tw
(') Tj
/F2 7.7 Tf 101.2 Tz
.79 Tw
(T OF) Tj
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
1.1 Tw
( I) Tj
/F2 7.7 Tf 101.2 Tz
.79 Tw
(NTERIOR) Tj
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
ET
Q
q
1 0 0 1 0 792 cm
0 G
.5 w 156 -140.25 m 456 -140.25 l s
Q
endstream
endobj
26 0 obj
4299
endobj
24 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Parent 10 0 R
/Resources <<
/Font <<
/F1 6 0 R
/F2 7 0 R
/F4 9 0 R
>>
/ProcSet 1 0 R
>>
/Contents 25 0 R
>>
endobj
%%Page: 7 7
28 0 obj
<<
/Length 29 0 R
>>
stream
q
BT
0 Tr
0 g
1 0 0 1 156 643.5 Tm
/F4 12 Tf 100 Tz
0 -8.4 Td
.81 Tw
0 Tc
(Adams) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
(, 847 F.2d 1315, 1318 \(9th Cir. 1988\)\). Lawrence pre-) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
2 Tw
(sented evidence that the BIA's policy affected some Indian) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
(employees, but he presented no evidence that the failure to) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
2.11 Tw
(provide actual and timely notice disproportionately affected) Tj
0 -13.2 Td
1.2 Tw
(Indians more than other racial groups. ) Tj
12 -26.2 Td
.14 Tw
(For the foregoing reasons, the judgment of the district court) Tj
-12 -13.2 Td
1.2 Tw
(is ) Tj
/F1 12 Tf 100 Tz
( ) Tj
/F1 12 Tf 100 Tz
12 -26.2 Td
(AFFIRMED) Tj
/F2 12 Tf 100 Tz
(. ) Tj
1 0 0 1 0 792 Tm
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
156 -136.5 Td
1.1 Tw
0 Tc
(5408) Tj
79.6318 0 Td
(L) Tj
/F2 7.7 Tf 101.2 Tz
.79 Tw
(AWRENCE) Tj
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
1.1 Tw
( v. D) Tj
/F2 7.7 Tf 101.2 Tz
.79 Tw
(EP) Tj
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
1.1 Tw
(') Tj
/F2 7.7 Tf 101.2 Tz
.79 Tw
(T OF) Tj
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
1.1 Tw
( I) Tj
/F2 7.7 Tf 101.2 Tz
.79 Tw
(NTERIOR) Tj
/F2 11 Tf 100 Tz
0 Ts
ET
Q
q
1 0 0 1 0 792 cm
0 G
.5 w 156 -140.25 m 456 -140.25 l s
Q
endstream
endobj
29 0 obj
1194
endobj
27 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Parent 30 0 R
/Resources <<
/Font <<
/F1 6 0 R
/F2 7 0 R
/F4 9 0 R
>>
/ProcSet 1 0 R
>>
/Contents 28 0 R
>>
endobj
1 0 obj
[ /PDF /Text ]
endobj
31 0 obj
<<
/Type /Encoding
/Differences [ 219 /Zcaron 135 /ccedilla 152 /ydieresis 243 /atilde 140 /icircumflex
31 /threesuperior 136 /ecircumflex 146 /thorn 138 /egrave 30 /twosuperior 130 /eacute
254 /otilde 155 /Aacute 147 /ocircumflex 217 /yacute 129 /udieresis 247 /threequarters
131 /acircumflex 190 /Eth 137 /edieresis 151 /ugrave 223 /trademark 149 /ograve 215 /scaron
228 /Idieresis 218 /uacute 133 /agrave 210 /ntilde 134 /aring 220 /zcaron 226 /Icircumflex
209 /Ntilde 150 /ucircumflex 159 /Ecircumflex 224 /Iacute 128 /Ccedilla 153 /Odieresis
214 /Scaron 176 /Edieresis 229 /Igrave 132 /adieresis 236 /Ograve 181 /Egrave 242 /Ydieresis
221 /registered 237 /Otilde 244 /onequarter 240 /Ugrave 239 /Ucircumflex 145 /Thorn
25 /divide 158 /Atilde 238 /Uacute 231 /Ocircumflex 29 /logicalnot 143 /Aring 139 /idieresis
252 /iacute 160 /aacute 27 /plusminus 26 /multiply 154 /Udieresis 28 /minus 204 /onesuperior
144 /Eacute 156 /Acircumflex 222 /copyright 157 /Agrave 148 /odieresis 253 /oacute 127 /degree
141 /igrave 201 /mu 230 /Oacute 192 /eth 142 /Adieresis 216 /Yacute 255 /brokenbar 246 /onehalf
]
>>
endobj
32 0 obj
<<
/Type /FontDescriptor
/FontName /Times-Bold
/Flags 34
/FontBBox [ -168 -218 1000 935 ]
/MissingWidth 250
/StemV 139.00
/StemH 69.50
/ItalicAngle 0.00
/CapHeight 676
/XHeight 461
/Ascent 676
/Descent -205
/Leading 0
/MaxWidth 0
/AvgWidth 0
>>
endobj
6 0 obj
<<
/Type /Font
/Subtype /Type1
/Name /F1
/BaseFont /Times-Bold
/FirstChar 0
/LastChar 255
/Widths [ 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250
250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 570 570 570 570 570 300 300
250 333 555 500 500 1000 833 333 333 333 500 570 250 333 250 278
500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 333 333 570 570 570 500
930 722 667 722 722 667 611 778 778 389 500 778 667 944 722 778
611 778 722 556 667 722 722 1000 722 722 667 333 278 333 581 500
333 500 556 444 556 444 333 500 556 278 333 556 278 833 556 500
556 556 444 389 333 556 500 722 500 500 444 394 220 394 520 400
722 556 444 500 500 500 500 444 444 444 444 278 278 278 722 722
667 611 556 500 500 500 556 556 500 778 722 722 722 722 722 667
500 333 500 500 167 500 500 500 500 278 500 500 333 333 556 556
667 500 500 500 250 667 540 350 333 500 500 500 1000 1000 722 500
500 333 333 333 333 333 333 333 333 556 333 333 300 333 333 333
1000 722 556 250 250 250 556 389 722 500 556 667 444 747 747 1000
389 1000 389 300 389 389 778 778 667 778 1000 330 778 778 722 722
722 722 722 500 750 278 750 750 278 500 722 556 278 500 500 220 ]
/Encoding 31 0 R
/FontDescriptor 32 0 R
>>
endobj
33 0 obj
<<
/Type /Encoding
/Differences [ 219 /Zcaron 135 /ccedilla 152 /ydieresis 243 /atilde 140 /icircumflex
31 /threesuperior 136 /ecircumflex 146 /thorn 138 /egrave 30 /twosuperior 130 /eacute
254 /otilde 155 /Aacute 147 /ocircumflex 217 /yacute 129 /udieresis 247 /threequarters
131 /acircumflex 190 /Eth 137 /edieresis 151 /ugrave 223 /trademark 149 /ograve 215 /scaron
228 /Idieresis 218 /uacute 133 /agrave 210 /ntilde 134 /aring 220 /zcaron 226 /Icircumflex
209 /Ntilde 150 /ucircumflex 159 /Ecircumflex 224 /Iacute 128 /Ccedilla 153 /Odieresis
214 /Scaron 176 /Edieresis 229 /Igrave 132 /adieresis 236 /Ograve 181 /Egrave 242 /Ydieresis
221 /registered 237 /Otilde 244 /onequarter 240 /Ugrave 239 /Ucircumflex 145 /Thorn
25 /divide 158 /Atilde 238 /Uacute 231 /Ocircumflex 29 /logicalnot 143 /Aring 139 /idieresis
252 /iacute 160 /aacute 27 /plusminus 26 /multiply 154 /Udieresis 28 /minus 204 /onesuperior
144 /Eacute 156 /Acircumflex 222 /copyright 157 /Agrave 148 /odieresis 253 /oacute 127 /degree
141 /igrave 201 /mu 230 /Oacute 192 /eth 142 /Adieresis 216 /Yacute 255 /brokenbar 246 /onehalf
]
>>
endobj
34 0 obj
<<
/Type /FontDescriptor
/FontName /Times-Roman
/Flags 34
/FontBBox [ -168 -218 1000 898 ]
/MissingWidth 250
/StemV 84.00
/StemH 42.00
/ItalicAngle 0.00
/CapHeight 662
/XHeight 450
/Ascent 683
/Descent -217
/Leading 0
/MaxWidth 0
/AvgWidth 0
>>
endobj
7 0 obj
<<
/Type /Font
/Subtype /Type1
/Name /F2
/BaseFont /Times-Roman
/FirstChar 0
/LastChar 255
/Widths [ 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250
250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 564 564 564 564 564 300 300
250 333 408 500 500 833 778 333 333 333 500 564 250 333 250 278
500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 278 278 564 564 564 444
921 722 667 667 722 611 556 722 722 333 389 722 611 889 722 722
556 722 667 556 611 722 722 944 722 722 611 333 278 333 469 500
333 444 500 444 500 444 333 500 500 278 278 500 278 778 500 500
500 500 333 389 278 500 500 722 500 500 444 480 200 480 541 400
667 500 444 444 444 444 444 444 444 444 444 278 278 278 722 722
611 556 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 722 722 722 722 722 722 611
444 333 500 500 167 500 500 500 500 180 444 500 333 333 556 556
611 500 500 500 250 611 453 350 333 444 444 500 1000 1000 722 444
500 333 333 333 333 333 333 333 333 500 333 333 300 333 333 333
1000 722 500 250 250 250 556 389 722 500 500 611 444 760 760 980
333 889 333 276 333 333 722 722 611 722 889 310 722 722 722 722
722 667 722 444 750 278 750 750 278 500 722 500 278 500 500 200 ]
/Encoding 33 0 R
/FontDescriptor 34 0 R
>>
endobj
35 0 obj
<<
/Type /Encoding
/Differences [ 240 /apple ]
>>
endobj
36 0 obj
<<
/Type /FontDescriptor
/FontName /Symbol
/Flags 4
/FontBBox [ -180 -293 1090 1010 ]
/MissingWidth 250
/StemV 85.00
/StemH 42.50
/ItalicAngle 0.00
/CapHeight 0
/XHeight 0
/Ascent 0
/Descent 0
/Leading 0
/MaxWidth 0
/AvgWidth 0
>>
endobj
8 0 obj
<<
/Type /Font
/Subtype /Type1
/Name /F3
/BaseFont /Symbol
/FirstChar 0
/LastChar 255
/Widths [ 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250
250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250
250 333 713 500 549 833 778 439 333 333 500 549 250 549 250 278
500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 278 278 549 549 549 444
549 722 667 722 612 611 763 603 722 333 631 722 686 889 722 722
768 741 556 592 611 690 439 768 645 795 611 333 863 333 658 500
500 631 549 549 494 439 521 411 603 329 603 549 549 576 521 549
549 521 549 603 439 576 713 686 493 686 494 480 200 480 549 250
250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250
250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250
250 620 247 549 167 713 500 753 753 753 753 1042 987 603 987 603
400 549 411 549 549 713 494 460 549 549 549 549 1000 603 1000 658
823 686 795 987 768 768 823 768 768 713 713 713 713 713 713 713
768 713 790 250 250 250 549 250 713 603 603 1042 987 603 987 603
494 329 790 790 786 713 384 384 384 384 384 384 494 494 494 494
790 329 274 686 686 686 384 384 384 384 384 384 494 494 494 250 ]
/Encoding 35 0 R
/FontDescriptor 36 0 R
>>
endobj
37 0 obj
<<
/Type /Encoding
/Differences [ 219 /Zcaron 135 /ccedilla 152 /ydieresis 243 /atilde 140 /icircumflex
31 /threesuperior 136 /ecircumflex 146 /thorn 138 /egrave 30 /twosuperior 130 /eacute
254 /otilde 155 /Aacute 147 /ocircumflex 217 /yacute 129 /udieresis 247 /threequarters
131 /acircumflex 190 /Eth 137 /edieresis 151 /ugrave 223 /trademark 149 /ograve 215 /scaron
228 /Idieresis 218 /uacute 133 /agrave 210 /ntilde 134 /aring 220 /zcaron 226 /Icircumflex
209 /Ntilde 150 /ucircumflex 159 /Ecircumflex 224 /Iacute 128 /Ccedilla 153 /Odieresis
214 /Scaron 176 /Edieresis 229 /Igrave 132 /adieresis 236 /Ograve 181 /Egrave 242 /Ydieresis
221 /registered 237 /Otilde 244 /onequarter 240 /Ugrave 239 /Ucircumflex 145 /Thorn
25 /divide 158 /Atilde 238 /Uacute 231 /Ocircumflex 29 /logicalnot 143 /Aring 139 /idieresis
252 /iacute 160 /aacute 27 /plusminus 26 /multiply 154 /Udieresis 28 /minus 204 /onesuperior
144 /Eacute 156 /Acircumflex 222 /copyright 157 /Agrave 148 /odieresis 253 /oacute 127 /degree
141 /igrave 201 /mu 230 /Oacute 192 /eth 142 /Adieresis 216 /Yacute 255 /brokenbar 246 /onehalf
]
>>
endobj
38 0 obj
<<
/Type /FontDescriptor
/FontName /Times-Italic
/Flags 98
/FontBBox [ -169 -217 1010 883 ]
/MissingWidth 250
/StemV 76.00
/StemH 38.00
/ItalicAngle -15.50
/CapHeight 653
/XHeight 441
/Ascent 683
/Descent -205
/Leading 0
/MaxWidth 0
/AvgWidth 0
>>
endobj
9 0 obj
<<
/Type /Font
/Subtype /Type1
/Name /F4
/BaseFont /Times-Italic
/FirstChar 0
/LastChar 255
/Widths [ 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250
250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 250 675 675 675 675 675 300 300
250 333 420 500 500 833 778 333 333 333 500 675 250 333 250 278
500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 333 333 675 675 675 500
920 611 611 667 722 611 611 722 722 333 444 667 556 833 667 722
611 722 611 500 556 722 611 833 611 556 556 389 278 389 422 500
333 500 500 444 500 444 278 500 500 278 278 444 278 722 500 500
500 500 389 389 278 500 444 667 444 444 389 400 275 400 541 400
667 500 444 500 500 500 500 444 444 444 444 278 278 278 611 611
611 611 500 500 500 500 500 500 444 722 722 611 611 611 611 611
500 389 500 500 167 500 500 500 500 214 556 500 333 333 500 500
611 500 500 500 250 611 523 350 333 556 556 500 889 1000 722 500
500 333 333 333 333 333 333 333 333 500 333 333 300 333 333 333
889 667 500 250 250 250 500 389 556 444 500 556 389 760 760 980
333 889 333 276 333 333 722 722 556 722 944 310 722 722 722 722
722 667 556 500 750 278 750 750 278 500 667 500 278 500 500 275 ]
/Encoding 37 0 R
/FontDescriptor 38 0 R
>>
endobj
39 0 obj
<<
/Type /Encoding
/Differences [ 219 /Zcaron 135 /ccedilla 152 /ydieresis 243 /atilde 140 /icircumflex
31 /threesuperior 136 /ecircumflex 146 /thorn 138 /egrave 30 /twosuperior 130 /eacute
254 /otilde 155 /Aacute 147 /ocircumflex 217 /yacute 129 /udieresis 247 /threequarters
131 /acircumflex 190 /Eth 137 /edieresis 151 /ugrave 223 /trademark 149 /ograve 215 /scaron
228 /Idieresis 218 /uacute 133 /agrave 210 /ntilde 134 /aring 220 /zcaron 226 /Icircumflex
209 /Ntilde 150 /ucircumflex 159 /Ecircumflex 224 /Iacute 128 /Ccedilla 153 /Odieresis
214 /Scaron 176 /Edieresis 229 /Igrave 132 /adieresis 236 /Ograve 181 /Egrave 242 /Ydieresis
221 /registered 237 /Otilde 244 /onequarter 240 /Ugrave 239 /Ucircumflex 145 /Thorn
25 /divide 158 /Atilde 238 /Uacute 231 /Ocircumflex 29 /logicalnot 143 /Aring 139 /idieresis
252 /iacute 160 /aacute 27 /plusminus 26 /multiply 154 /Udieresis 28 /minus 204 /onesuperior
144 /Eacute 156 /Acircumflex 222 /copyright 157 /Agrave 148 /odieresis 253 /oacute 127 /degree
141 /igrave 201 /mu 230 /Oacute 192 /eth 142 /Adieresis 216 /Yacute 255 /brokenbar 246 /onehalf
]
>>
endobj
40 0 obj
<<
/Type /FontDescriptor
/FontName /Helvetica-Bold
/Flags 32
/FontBBox [ -170 -228 1003 962 ]
/MissingWidth 250
/StemV 140.00
/StemH 70.00
/ItalicAngle 0.00
/CapHeight 718
/XHeight 532
/Ascent 718
/Descent -207
/Leading 0
/MaxWidth 0
/AvgWidth 0
>>
endobj
17 0 obj
<<
/Type /Font
/Subtype /Type1
/Name /F5
/BaseFont /Helvetica-Bold
/FirstChar 0
/LastChar 255
/Widths [ 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278
278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 278 584 584 584 584 584 333 333
278 333 474 556 556 889 722 278 333 333 389 584 278 333 278 278
556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 333 333 584 584 584 611
975 722 722 722 722 667 611 778 722 278 556 722 611 833 722 778
667 778 722 667 611 722 667 944 667 667 611 333 278 333 584 556
278 556 611 556 611 556 333 611 611 278 278 556 278 889 611 611
611 611 389 556 333 611 556 778 556 556 500 389 280 389 584 400
722 611 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 278 278 278 722 722
667 667 611 611 611 611 611 611 556 778 722 722 722 722 722 667
556 333 556 556 167 556 556 556 556 238 500 556 333 333 611 611
667 556 556 556 278 667 556 350 278 500 500 556 1000 1000 722 611
611 333 333 333 333 333 333 333 333 611 333 333 333 333 333 333
1000 722 611 278 278 278 667 556 667 556 611 611 500 737 737 1000
278 1000 278 370 278 278 778 778 611 778 1000 365 778 778 722 722
722 889 667 556 834 278 834 834 278 611 944 611 278 611 611 280 ]
/Encoding 39 0 R
/FontDescriptor 40 0 R
>>
endobj
10 0 obj
<<
/Kids [3 0 R 11 0 R 14 0 R 18 0 R 21 0 R 24 0 R]
/Count 6
/Type /Pages
/Parent 41 0 R
>>
endobj
30 0 obj
<<
/Kids [27 0 R]
/Count 1
/Type /Pages
/Parent 41 0 R
>>
endobj
41 0 obj
<<
/Kids [10 0 R 30 0 R]
/Count 7
/Type /Pages
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
2 0 obj
<<
/Type /Catalog
/Pages 41 0 R
>>
endobj
42 0 obj
<<
/CreationDate (Monday May 12, 2008 08:28:35)
/Creator (VERSACOMP R05.2)
/Producer (ECMP5)
>>
endobj
xref
0 43
0000000000 65535 f
0000025163 00000 n
0000037651 00000 n
0000003328 00000 n
0000000044 00000 n
0000003305 00000 n
0000026628 00000 n
0000029280 00000 n
0000030834 00000 n
0000033481 00000 n
0000037355 00000 n
0000006177 00000 n
0000003542 00000 n
0000006153 00000 n
0000010267 00000 n
0000006371 00000 n
0000010243 00000 n
0000036132 00000 n
0000014726 00000 n
0000010484 00000 n
0000014702 00000 n
0000018910 00000 n
0000014943 00000 n
0000018886 00000 n
0000023499 00000 n
0000019115 00000 n
0000023475 00000 n
0000024983 00000 n
0000023704 00000 n
0000024959 00000 n
0000037471 00000 n
0000025196 00000 n
0000026348 00000 n
0000027848 00000 n
0000029000 00000 n
0000030496 00000 n
0000030568 00000 n
0000032046 00000 n
0000033198 00000 n
0000034696 00000 n
0000035848 00000 n
0000037553 00000 n
0000037707 00000 n
trailer
<<
/Size 43
/Root 2 0 R
/Info 42 0 R
>>
startxref
37844
%%EOF
2 0 obj
<>
endobj
43 0 obj
<>
endobj
44 0 obj
<>stream
Monday May 12, 2008 08:28:35
ECMP5
VERSACOMP R05.2
2008-05-15T12:44-06:00
2008-05-15T12:44-06:00
2008-05-15T12:44-06:00
application/pdf
Lawrence v. Department of Interior
uuid:186ee65e-a376-4363-9a82-4711af77eb36
uuid:f80945fd-97fe-421b-8991-e2f5edfa6d5a
endstream
endobj
xref
2 1
0000038795 00000 n
43 2
0000038857 00000 n
0000039086 00000 n
trailer
<]/Prev 37844 >>
startxref
42812
%%EOF
44 0 obj
<>stream
Monday May 12, 2008 08:28:35
ECMP5
VERSACOMP R05.2
2008-05-15T12:44:24-06:00
2008-05-15T12:44-06:00
2008-05-15T12:44:24-06:00
application/pdf
Lawrence v. Department of Interior (Opinion)
uuid:186ee65e-a376-4363-9a82-4711af77eb36
uuid:134e26ce-8d48-4d9a-8b2f-50f56b678ccd
endstream
endobj
45 0 obj
<>
endobj
xref
44 2
0000043045 00000 n
0000046787 00000 n
trailer
<<4C65E930660D8D40992C818ECC56BDD3>]/Prev 42812 >>
startxref
47028
%%EOF