FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE: Dec. 28, 2006
For Further Information Contact: Don Wharton (303) 447-8760
To support our efforts in this important legal battle on behalf of the Tribes we represent, please click here to make a secure online contribution. Thank you for your support.
Tribes File Trust Funds Mismanagement Lawsuit Against Federal Government
BOULDER, CO – The Native American Rights Fund (NARF), a non-profit law firm in Boulder, Colorado announced today that it has filed a class action lawsuit in federal district court in Washington, D.C. on behalf of over two hundred and fifty (250) Indian Tribes. The suit seeks full and complete accountings from the federal government for hundreds of tribal accounts worth billions of dollars that are held in trust by the United States. The federal government long ago assumed the role of trustee for tribal trust funds, and created the accounts at issue. The funds come from revenues from tribal natural resources such as timber, minerals, oil and gas; court judgments entered against the United States for the unlawful appropriation of Indian land and property; and, income from the investments of money held in the accounts. The federal government gave Tribes no choice about the creation of these trust fund accounts, some of which date back to the 1800s.
NARF Executive Director John Echohawk explained recent events leading up to the lawsuit: "By the early 1980s, Tribes increasingly were concerned that they could not get accountings of their trust funds. The Government Accounting Office (GAO) and the U.S. Department of the Interiors Office of the Inspector General (OIG), issued key reports that identified major problems in the governments management of tribal and individual Indian trust funds. The reports detailed records lost or never kept, systems that didnt work or werent coordinated, and policies that were deficient or never even existed. In 1987, Congress began ordering the Interior Department to audit and reconcile the accounts — which never had been done — and to provide full and complete accountings of the funds to Tribes and individual Indians whose money was in the accounts. In 2003 the GAO stated that notwithstanding some improvements, Indian trust fund account holders have no assurance that their account balances are accurate. And as recently as 2005, the OIG reported that Interior Department procedures and controls were not adequate to ensure that Indian trust fund activities and balances were recorded properly or timely. The bottom line is that despite the agency reports and twenty (20) years of congressional mandates no adequate accountings have resulted to date."
The governments only response has been far short of full and complete accountings. In the 1990s, the Bureau of Indian Affairs within the Interior Department contracted with the accounting firm of Arthur Andersen, LLP, to do a very limited reconciliation of tribal trust fund accounts. Even though Arthur Andersen, the Interior Department, and the GAO all have acknowledged the Arthur Andersen reconciliation project shortcomings, the government has tried repeatedly to get Tribes to accept the Arthur Andersen reconciliation reports as full and complete accountings of their trust funds, thereby avoiding its basic trust responsibilities.
Efforts by Congress to resolve the situation have failed. Moreover, in 2002 Congress, concerned about the governments potential liability for Indian trust fund mismanagement — estimated by the government itself to be in the hundreds of billions of dollars — gave Tribes a deadline of December 31, 2005 by which to challenge the accounting adequacy of the Arthur Andersen reconciliation reports. In December 2005, Congress extended this deadline for one year until December 31, 2006. But this year Congress has refused to extend the deadline any further.
Given this deadline, the only recourse for Tribes is to file a lawsuit by December 31, 2006 seeking a court order declaring that the Arthur Andersen reconciliation reports are not full and complete accountings, and requiring the government to provide such accountings according to court-ordered standards. As many as fifty (50) Tribes to date have filed lawsuits on their own behalf. But over two hundred and fifty (250) other tribes either do not have the financial resources or the needed information to file their suits by the end of this calendar year. NARF thus filed a class action lawsuit to protect those Tribes who do not file their own lawsuits from forever losing their rights to challenge the adequacy of the Arthur Andersen reconciliation reports and to get full and complete trust fund accountings from the government. The Chairman of NARFs Board of Directors, John Gonzales, stated, We are confident that the court will agree that the Arthur Andersen reconciliation reports are not full and complete accountings. The real battle will be over what more the court or Congress will do to protect the rights of Tribes and hold the government accountable for its duties as the trustee for tribal trust funds.
Eleven Tribes — the Nez Perce Tribe, the Mescalero Apache Tribe, the Tule River Indian Tribe, the Hualapai Tribe, the Yakama Nation, the Klamath Tribes, the Yurok Tribe, the Cheyenne-Arapaho Tribe, the Pawnee Nation of Oklahoma, the Sac and Fox Nation, and the Santee Sioux Tribe of Nebraska — are the named plaintiff Tribes in the lawsuit. Rebecca Miles, Chair of the lead named plaintiff the Nez Perce Tribe, commented that, "This lawsuit is a reflection of a huge historical problem with the federal governments mismanagement of tribal trust accounts. We have tried to work with the agencies and we have tried to work with Congress. Our hope now is with the courts. We are pleased to step forward with NARF in leading this fight for Indian justice."
The Native American Rights Fund is a non-profit organization that has been protecting the legal and sovereign rights of tribes and Native people within the American legal system for more than 36 years. NARF is headquartered in Boulder, Colorado with offices in Anchorage, Alaska, and Washington, D.C.To support our efforts in this important legal battle on behalf of the Tribes we represent, please click here to make a secure online contribution. Thank you for your support.
Updated April, 12, 2010